USU Associate of Applied Science Degree Nursing Program: Systematic Plan of Evaluation

Standard 5 Outcomes

Nursing program assessment demonstrates the extent of student learning at or near the end of the program as well as program outcome achievement using a systematic plan for evaluation (SPE).

The faculty create and implement a written SPE* for each nursing program type to determine the extent of the achievement of each end-of-program student learning outcome and program outcome, and additionally for graduate programs the role-specific nursing competencies, to inform program decision-making to maintain or improve student and program performance.

Criterion 5.1

The systematic plan for evaluation describes the process for regular summative nursing program-level assessment of student learning outcome achievement. The faculty will:

  1. use a variety of appropriate direct outcome assessment methods to ensure comprehensive summative assessment for each end-of-program student learning outcome;
  2. establish a specific, measurable expected level of achievement outcome statement for each summative assessment method;
  3. collect aggregate assessment data at regular intervals (determined by the faculty) to ensure sufficiency of data to inform decision-making and disaggregate the data to promote meaningful analysis; provide justification for data that are not disaggregated;
  4. analyze assessment data (aggregate and/or disaggregate) at regular intervals (determined by the faculty) and when necessary, implement actions based on the analysis to maintain and/or improve end-of-program student learning outcome achievement;
  5. maintain documentation for the three most recent years of the assessment data (aggregate and/or disaggregate), the analysis of data, and the use of data analysis in program decision-making to maintain and/or improve students’ end-of-program student learning outcome achievement; and
  6. share the analysis of the end-of-program student learning outcome data with communities of interest

End-of-Program Student Learning Outcome and Program Outcomes

PLAN Implementation
Component Assessment Method(s)* Expected Level of Achievement Frequency of Assessment Results of Data Collection

Including actual level(s) of achievement
Analysis and Actions for Program Development, Maintenance, or Revision
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination The composite score (adjusted group score) for the cohort on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. During final semester of the program 2023: Group score: 74.8% (National mean: 71.8%)

2022: Group score: 74.9% (National mean: 71.8%)

2021: Group score: 78.0% (National mean: 69%)
2023: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2022 ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met, will continue to monitor.
EPSLO #1: Critical Thinking

Demonstrate proficiency while performing nursing skills incorporating nursing judgment and evidence-based practice
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care
-Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 
Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool.
Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 4 (2020): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 7 (2023): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Year 10 (2026): SLOs 1, 2, & 3
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met in the Final Clinical Evaluation Tool and Nursing Exit Survey categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of Clinical Judgement.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars. Removing outdated online learning platform and adding new platform that can be utilized in-class, lab, simulation, and clinical to improve clinical judgement. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in the Final Clinical Evaluation Tool and Nursing Exit Survey categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of Clinical Judgement.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars under assumption lower scores due to COVID stressors.   
See curriculum review in May 2021 faculty retreat minutes.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 87.2% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 85%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Nursing Judgment category The composite score for the cohort on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Nursing Judgment category will be at least 75%. SP 2023: 73.6% (Target: >75%)  

SP 2022: 75% (Target: >75%)  

SP 2020: 74.5% (Target:>75%)
EPSLO #2: Holism

Apply holistic principles while caring for individuals, families, and communities across the lifespan.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 

Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool.
Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 4 (2020): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 7 (2023): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Year 10 (2026): SLOs 1, 2, & 3
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey. < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses. A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 87.2% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 83%
1) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Psychosocial Integrity category 1) The composite score for the cohort in the Psychosocial Integrity category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 74.8% (5.8 % above national mean) 

SP 2022: 70.8% (.01% above national mean mean)

SP 2021: 73.5% (4.0% above program mean) 
2) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Physiological Adaptation category 2) The composite score for the cohort in the Physiological Adaptation category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 77.9% (10.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 70.7% (1.3% above national mean) 

 SP 2021: 75.1% (7.0% above national mean)
3) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Pharmacological and Parenteral Therapies category The composite score for the cohort in the Pharmacological and Parenteral Therapies category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 75.2% (8.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 74.7% (7.8% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 76.3% (9.7% above national mean)
EPSLO #3: Nursing Process and Safety

Establish priorities and ensure safe, quality care while utilizing the nursing process.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 

Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool.
Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 4 (2020): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 7 (2023): SLOs 1, 2, & 3 

Year 10 (2026): SLOs 1, 2, & 3
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met in the Final Clinical Evaluation Tool and Nursing Exit Survey categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of Reduction of Risk.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars.  Removing outdated online learning platform and adding new platform that can be utilized in-class, lab, simulation, and clinical to improve reduction of risk learning. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses.  A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of B.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars under assumption lower scores due to COVID stressors.

See curriculum review in May 2021 faculty retreat minutes.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 87.2% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 83%
1) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Management of Care category 1) The composite score for the cohort in the Management of Care category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 79.8% (4.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 78.3% (2.5% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 80.1% (12.2% above program mean)
2) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Safety and Infection Control category 2) The composite score for the cohort in the Safety and Infection Control category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 75.6% (1.5% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 78.3% (4.9% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 79.6% (6.4% above national mean)
3) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Basic Care and Comfort category 3) The composite score for the cohort in the Basic Care and Comfort category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 69.9% (0.1% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 74.6% (7.5% above program mean) 

SP 2021: 67.6% (2.0% below national mean)
4) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Pharmacological and Parenteral Therapies category 4) The composite score for the cohort in the Pharmacological and Parenteral Therapies category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 75.2% (8.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 74.7% (7.8% above national mean)

SP 2021: 76.3% (9.7% above national mean)
5) ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Reduction of Risk category 5) The composite score for the cohort in the Reduction of Risk category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 70.1% (6.1% below national mean) 

SP 2022: 77.8% (4.4% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 75.4% (1.3% above program mean)
EPSLO #4: Communication 

Model effective communication and leadership when collaborating within interdisciplinary teams.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care-Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool. Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 5 (2021): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 8 (2024): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Year 11 (2027): SLOs 4, 5, & 6
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools and ATI Predictor Exam categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses. A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 87.2% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 78%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Manager of Care category The composite score for the cohort in the Manager of Care category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 79.8% (4.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 78.3% (2.5% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 80.1% (12.2% above program mean)
EPSLO #5: Ethics

Model accountability in nursing practice while adhering to legal and ethical principles.

NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool. Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 5 (2021): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 8 (2024): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Year 11 (2027): SLOs 4, 5, & 6
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools and ATI Predictor Exam categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses.  A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 89.4% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 83%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Manager of Care category The composite score for the cohort in the Manager of Care category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 79.8% (4.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 78.3% (2.5% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 80.1% (12.2% above program mean)
EPSLO #6: Advocacy and Leadership

Advocate for professional and leadership role development in self and others.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool. Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 5 (2021): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 8 (2024): SLOs 4, 5, & 6 

Year 11 (2027): SLOs 4, 5, & 6
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools and ATI Predictor Exam categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses.  A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 87.2% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 82%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Manager of Care category The composite score for the cohort in the Manager of Care category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 79.8% (4.4% above national mean) 

SP 2022: 78.3% (2.5% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 80.1% (12.2% above program mean)
EPSLO #7: Education and Health Promotion

Implement teaching plans and health promotion in a variety of settings across the lifespan.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool. Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 6 (2022): SLOs 7 & 8 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 9 (2025): SLOs 7 & 8 

Year 12 (2028): SLOs 7 & 8
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met in the Final Clinical Evaluation Tool and Nursing Exit Survey categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of Health Promotion & Maintenance.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars.  Removing outdated online learning platform and adding new platform that can be utilized in-class, lab, simulation, and clinical to improve reduction of risk learning. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools and ATI Predictor Exam categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses. A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 90.6% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 82%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Health Promotion and Maintenance category The composite score for the cohort in the Health Promotion and Maintenance category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 64.1% (1.0% below national mean) 

SP 2022: 72% (10% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 71.5% (9.4% above program mean) 
EPSLO #8: Respectful Care

Serve as a caring and respectful advocate in promoting hope, health, and healing, while preserving human dignity.
NURS 2230 
Manager of Care -Clinical
final clinical evaluation tool
100% of students completing NURS 2230 Manager of Care - Clinical will receive rankings of satisfactory on each component of the final clinical evaluation tool. Annually for 3 years: All SLOs (2017-2019) 

Year 6 (2022): SLOs 7 & 8 

Rotating cycle to be repeated pending results 

Year 9 (2025): SLOs 7 & 8 

Year 12 (2028): SLOs 7 & 8
SP 2023: 100% 

SP 2022: 100% 

SP 2021: 100%
2023: ELA met in the Final Clinical Evaluation Tool and Nursing Exit Survey categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in the ATI Comp. Predictor category of Psychosocial Integrity.  Action plan:  No changes to current concepts or exemplars.  Removing outdated online learning platform and adding new platform that can be utilized in-class, lab, simulation, and clinical to improve reduction of risk learning. 

2022: ELA met, will continue to monitor. 

2021: ELA met in Final Clinical Evaluation Tools and ATI Predictor Exam categories, will continue to monitor. 

ELA not met in Nursing Exit Survey.  < 85% aggregate score was determined to be caused by one campus and one cohort who were dissatisfied in one of their major courses.  A Performance Improvement Plan was initiated with faculty involved for the 2021/2022 AY.
USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey item: end-of-program student learning outcomes 85% of students agree that they were able to achieve each end-of-program student learning outcome (SLO) on the USU Department of Nursing Exit Survey. SP 2023: 90.6% 

SP 2022: 98% 

SP 2021: 84%
ATI Comprehensive Predictor Examination Psychosocial Integrity category The composite score for the cohort in the Psychosocial Integrity category on the ATI Comprehensive Predictor examination will be at or above the group national mean. SP 2023: 70.1% (6.1 % below national mean) 

SP 2022: 77.8% (4.7% above national mean) 

SP 2021: 75.4% (1.3% above program mean)